Lawrence “Larry” Glen Orenstein, a beloved pillar of the Tucson community and a cherished husband, father, brother, and friend, passed away on February 26, 2024, in San Tan Valley, AZ, surrounded by his loving family, at the age of 85.
Larry was born on April 8, 1938, in Buffalo, NY, to Joseph and Bertha Orenstein. The family later relocated to Brooklyn, NY. Larry’s adventurous spirit was evident from his earliest days of youth. He was a passionate member and leader of the Boy Scouts of America, achieving the distinction of Arrowman by the Order of the Arrow.
After graduating from Lafayette High School in Brooklyn, Larry met the love of his life, Susan, on a blind date in Brooklyn. Their whirlwind romance led to 64 years of marriage filled with cherished memories of trips around the world.
Larry’s life took a patriotic turn when he was drafted by the Army as a radio operator, narrowly avoiding deployment during the Cuban Missile Crisis. Following his military service, Larry and Susan settled on Long Island, where they had four children. After a variety of jobs in manufacturing and carpentry, he fell into an opportunity that would allow him to start his own business and provide for his growing family. He opened the thriving Bagels to GoGo in Huntington, NY where hours-long lines formed out the door to taste his savory bagels.
Tired of the New York winters, the family later moved to Tucson, AZ where Larry established The Bagelry, a beloved New York-themed chain of bagel shops, which served as an oasis for New York transplants. Known for his disarming charm, infectious laugh, and unwavering Brooklyn accent, he quickly became a prominent figure in the small business community. He was one of the leading voices of the Campbell Avenue Association, advocating fiercely against a construction project proposed by the city of Tucson that would have threatened the survival of his and many other small businesses. For over 20 years, Larry touched the lives of countless patrons and employees alike, winning local awards for best bagel shop and best breakfast.
Larry’s children remember him not only as a successful businessman but also as a teacher of resilience. When The Bagelry once caught fire, causing significant damage and forcing a temporary closure, Larry wasted no time in bouncing back. Within days, they were up and running at an Italian bakery, making do with borrowed equipment—a testament to Larry’s never-ending determination.
Larry’s passion for automobiles was legendary, having owned an impressive 62 cars over the years. His favorites included a couple of British roadsters, the Triumph TR6 and MGB, vehicles he would joyfully take for spirited drives, often with family members in tow. His son Seth fondly recalls the exhilarating rides in the MGB, gripping onto dear life as Larry expertly navigated corners, laughter filling the air. Larry’s brother Sandy remembers Larry’s infectious enthusiasm as he eagerly anticipated getting behind the wheel of Sandy’s Sunbeam Alpine. His daughter Stacey remembers him patiently sitting beside her, teaching her how to drive in a Suzuki Samurai as she stalled the car multiple times.
Eternally devoted to his family, Larry cared for his parents and in-laws during times of need. He was able to fix anything and had a wide range of knowledge. He was a hero, role model and his positive spirit and can-do attitude led the family through all the celebrations and challenges of life.
Larry is survived by his devoted wife, Susan; four loving children: Amy Loren, Stacey Sherman, Seth and Josh Orenstein; eight grandchildren; one great-grandson; brother Sandy (Ina); sister-in-law Janet; brother-in-law Chuck; and extended family. Words can not express how deeply he is missed and his spirit of resilience, love, and laughter will forever live on in the hearts of those who knew him.
The Orenstein family would like to extend their heartfelt gratitude to all who supported them during this difficult time, especially Shaniquka Lee, Arizona Care Hospice, and the Phoenix VA. A funeral service to honor Larry’s life will be held at San Tan Memorial Gardens on February 29, 2024, at 10am. For further inquiries, please contact San Tan Memorial Gardens at 480-987-2488.
